Detective Comics #58
1st appearance of the Penguin
Trap checkDon't buy these
22 listingson eBay right now look like this issue but aren't it — usually the cheapest ones on the page. Here's what's wrong with each, so you don't buy the wrong book.
- ViewFacsimile / reprint$6.95
Detective Comics #58 (2023 DC Comics) Facsimile Edition
A modern reprint of the original cover. Often looks identical in photos, but it is not the collectible book — these sell for a few dollars.
- ViewFacsimile / reprint$6.99
Detective Comics #58 Facsimile Edition
A modern reprint of the original cover. Often looks identical in photos, but it is not the collectible book — these sell for a few dollars.
- ViewFacsimile / reprint$6.99
DETECTIVE COMICS #58 FACSIMILE EDITION - 1st APP OF THE PENGUIN - DC COMICS/2023
A modern reprint of the original cover. Often looks identical in photos, but it is not the collectible book — these sell for a few dollars.
- ViewFacsimile / reprint$6.99
DETECTIVE COMICS #58 FACSIMILE EDITION FRED RAY COVER A VARIANT (DC COMICS 2025)
A modern reprint of the original cover. Often looks identical in photos, but it is not the collectible book — these sell for a few dollars.
- ViewFacsimile / reprint$7.27
Detective Comics #58 Facsimile J. Robinson & F. Ray 2023 🔑 Key Issue VF+
A modern reprint of the original cover. Often looks identical in photos, but it is not the collectible book — these sell for a few dollars.
- ViewFacsimile / reprint$7.34
Detective Comics #58 Facsimile Edition
A modern reprint of the original cover. Often looks identical in photos, but it is not the collectible book — these sell for a few dollars.
- ViewFacsimile / reprint$7.99
DETECTIVE COMICS 58 Facsimile (2023 ) - Reprints 1st Appearance of The Penguin
A modern reprint of the original cover. Often looks identical in photos, but it is not the collectible book — these sell for a few dollars.
- ViewFacsimile / reprint$7.99
DETECTIVE COMICS #58 PENGUIN 1ST APPEARANCE FACSIMILE EDITION 2023
A modern reprint of the original cover. Often looks identical in photos, but it is not the collectible book — these sell for a few dollars.
Should you buy that copy?
Looking at a specific listing? Paste its eBay link — we'll read the copy and tell you if it's the right book and how the price sits against real sales. No link? Paste the title instead.
An estimate of what this grade is worth today, not a record of any sale. Guide values are trailing aggregates, so they lag a fast-moving book — a copy that just sold at auction may have gone for well above or below this.
Where the copies sit
Guide value
| Updated | Grade | Estimate |
|---|---|---|
| Aug 29, 2026 | CGC 9.2 | $24,906.00 |
Seen these sell? Add the sales
Paste recent sold results — from eBay's completed listings, a price guide, or your own purchases. We auto-detect the grade and flag the wrong books; you confirm.
Find a copy to buy
None on eBay right now? These open a pre-filled search for this exact book across the places collectors hunt.
- eBay — active listingsEverything for sale now, beyond the copies we track
- eBay — sold, completedWhat copies actually fetched — sanity-check any asking price
- MyComicShopMajor back-issue dealer stock, raw and slabbed
- MercariOften cheaper, with fewer collectors watching
- AbeBooksIndependent booksellers — good for raw copies
- AmazonThird-party comic sellers, occasionally slabbed
- Google ShoppingSweeps shops and marketplaces not listed above
- Auction houses & dealersHeritage, ComicConnect, ComicLink and specialist shops